Edinburgh restaurants - Our Expert's
Top 40

Sort by

Javascript is required to view this map.
#1/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Best for Gourmets -
Expert overall rating:5.0 (out of 5)

World-class food from a Michelin-starred chef.

Read full expert review

Ondine

Price guide: Mid-range
#2/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Best for Dining alone -
Expert overall rating:4.8 (out of 5)

Award-winning seafood restaurant - kill to get a table.

Read full expert review

The Kitchin

Price guide: Expensive
#3/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.8 (out of 5)

Fabulous Michelin-starred restaurant on Edinburgh's waterfront.

Read full expert review

The Plumed Horse

Price guide: Mid-range
#4/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.8 (out of 5)

The Plumed Horse has a Michelin star, an owner with a big personality and fab food.

Read full expert review

La Garrigue

Price guide: Mid-range
#5/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.7 (out of 5)

A charming and authentic French restaurant.

Read full expert review

Harvey Nichols

Price guide: Mid-range
#6/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Best for Outdoor dining -
Expert overall rating:4.7 (out of 5)

Panoramic views from the Harvey Nichols' restaurant on the fourth floor.

Read full expert review

David Bann

Price guide: Mid-range
#7/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.7 (out of 5)

Modern, imaginative vegetarian food in stylish surroundings.

Read full expert review

Dusit

Price guide: Mid-range
#8/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.6 (out of 5)

Fresh and delicious Thai food.

Read full expert review

Wedgwood the Restaurant

Price guide: Mid-range
#9/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
No image
Expert overall rating:4.6 (out of 5)

The best seasonal Scottish food served in a glorious setting on The Royal Mile.

Read full expert review

Karens Unicorn

Price guide: Mid-range
#10/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.6 (out of 5)

The freshest ingredients mark this as the best Chinese restaurant in the city.

Read full expert review

The Witchery

Price guide: Expensive
#11/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Best for Romance -
Expert overall rating:4.6 (out of 5)

The most atmospheric and romantic restaurant in Edinburgh.

Read full expert review

The Outsider

Price guide: Mid-range
#12/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.6 (out of 5)

Trendy and spacious, with fabulous views over the old town and castle.

Read full expert review

Sweet Melindas

Price guide: Mid-range
#13/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.6 (out of 5)

A charming restaurant, with the emphasis on fish, sourced and produced by the passionate chef.

Read full expert review

Hanedan

Price guide: Budget
#14/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Best for Value for money -
Expert overall rating:4.6 (out of 5)

A small, friendly Turkish restaurant with a wonderful atmosphere and great food.

Read full expert review

Peter's Yard

Price guide: Mid-range
#15/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.6 (out of 5)

Dreamy Swedish bakery and coffee shop with sublime fresh food in the university quarter.

Read full expert review

The Circle Cafe

Price guide: Budget
#16/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.5 (out of 5)

A warm and inviting, stone walled emporium of delicious home-made food.

Read full expert review

Cafe Marlayne

Price guide: Mid-range
#17/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.5 (out of 5)

An intimate French bistro with a great atmosphere and delicious food.

Read full expert review

Cuckoo's Bakery

Price guide: Budget
#18/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.5 (out of 5)

You would be cuckoo not to try this!

Read full expert review

The Dogs

Price guide: Budget
#19/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Best for Trendiness -
Expert overall rating:4.5 (out of 5)

Keen prices, imaginative dishes, eccentric owner - The Dogs is a one-off, well worth a visit.

Read full expert review

Mussel Inn

Price guide: Mid-range
#20/40
expert-rated restaurants in Edinburgh
Expert overall rating:4.5 (out of 5)

Informal diner with great seafood, bang in the centre of town.

Read full expert review
Showing 1-20 of 40 results
Set focus

There are hundreds of great places to eat and drink in Edinburgh. Really we have come a long way from ye olde days of deep fried Mars Bars and haggis pies. There has been a revolution in the standard and food being both produced and cooked in this country.

With six Michelin-starred restaurants in the Edinburgh area alone, other restaurants and food producers have raised their game. As a result you will be spoiled for choice. Whether you want to spend a few quid or a shed load of money you can pick and choose the kind of food you like to eat in the atmosphere you like to eat it.

I have featured three of the Michelin-starred restaurants in town because they are my favourites. I will of course list the names of the others but I felt that, as Michelin is already a known standard, I should perhaps draw your attention to smaller, lesser-known establishments which would be easy to overlook.

Every country seems to have a different policy on tipping but here it is generally left to the discrepancy of the customer. As a rule of thumb I  recommend 10% of the total bill. Sometimes if you have party of 8 or over they will automatically charge you 10% but it should state that clearly on their website or when you book. Occasionally a restaurant will add an automatic 10% service charge even if there are just one or two of you which I don't agree with and I have  insisted they take the service charge off to make the point. I am happy to generously tip if the service is good, if not, I don't.

Set focus

Each of the restaurants/cafes/coffee shops I have featured offer value for money, great food, consistency and excellent service. I have been involved in the restaurant industry in Edinburgh, both as a consumer and a professional, for over 20 years. During that time my husband started his own restaurant and expanded until we had eight sites in Scotland, he sold them three years ago - so there is no conflict of interest! In addition I was food critic for The Sunday Herald for a year, presented two series of food programmes on STV and was a judge in Channel 4's new food show Iron Chef. I have also been a judge for Restaurant of the Year for the past two years and am going through the process again late 2010 to be announcend February 2012/ To be frank, food is my obsession. I eat out all the time and I am very proud of what Edinburgh can offer.

Geographically I have tried to cover all areas of the city, with a natural concentration in the centre. I hope you find somewhere close to where you are staying. If not please let me know as feedback from you is paramount and I can rectify things.

On an ongoing basis  I will keep my ear to the ground and review any new additions to the Edinburgh food scene, as well as monitoring all featured restaurants with a view to making sure what you read on this list is accurate as it is important you can rely on this.

Cheers! Enjoy! 

Regards, Alison

1st November, 2010